Gerrit Cole Waited for the Perfect Second to Throw His First Pitch and It Was the Last Good Decision He Made All Afternoon

Gerrit Cole stood on the mound, ball in hand, ready to go.

Then he just… waited. On purpose. For the clock.

What happened the exact moment he finally let it fly is why this clip is still spreading a day later.

He Had a Minute to Spare and Used Every Second of It

Cole finished his warmups a full minute before Saturday's scheduled 1:38 p.m. first pitch against the Mets, and instead of throwing early, he simply stood there, staring down the Yankee Stadium clock, making 46,864 fans and Francisco Lindor wait it out with him. Jomboy Media caught the whole thing on video and posted it with the caption that basically wrote itself: "Gerrit Cole refused to start the game before the official start time, and then allowed a leadoff home run."

The pitch, when it finally came, was an 85 mph changeup. Lindor didn't miss it. Solo shot, first batter of the game, and the Bronx crowd got its answer for why Cole might have wanted those extra seconds in the first place — he clearly didn't need them.

It Only Got Worse From There

Cole lasted just 4.1 innings, allowing five earned runs on nine hits, with three of those hits leaving the yard entirely. The Mets piled on six total home runs as a team, including a Juan Soto blast in his first trip back to Yankee Stadium since leaving for Queens, and closed it out with a Lindor grand slam in the eighth. Final score: 12-2, Mets, evening up the Subway Series ahead of Sunday's rubber match.

This wasn't a one-off, either. It was the second straight start in which Cole surrendered a home run to the very first batter he faced, and the second straight start overall in which the long ball buried him — he'd given up four solo shots, including three straight to open the game, in his previous outing against San Diego. Across his career, Cole now owns an 8.49 ERA in ten starts against the Mets specifically, the worst matchup of his career against any team not named the Red Sox.

Nobody's Sure Why He Did It, and That's Half the Fun

It's still not clear whether waiting for the exact start time was an umpire directive or just Cole being Cole — a pitcher who has never hidden how routine-driven and particular he is about his pre-game process. Whatever it was, the optics turned brutal the second Lindor's ball left the yard. Fans didn't need an explanation to pile on. One clip, one home run, and Cole's insistence on doing things by the book turned into the most-discussed moment of an afternoon that ended in a rout.

The Yankees now sit four games back of the division-leading Rays with 14 left to play, and whatever happens with Cole down the stretch, this is the image that's going to follow him into it — a $324 million ace who had a golden chance to catch Lindor off guard early, chose precision over instinct, and got taken deep before the ink was even dry on the moment.


Sources:

  • Yardbarker/EssentiallySports, "Yankees' $324M Star's Strange Pre-Game Decision Backfires as He Gets Punished Right Away," September 2026.
  • AOL, "'All That To Get Smoked By Mets' – Fans Troll Gerrit Cole After Yankees Ace Refuses Early Start, Concedes Leadoff HR to Francisco Lindor," September 2026.
  • Associated Press via Yahoo Sports, "Francisco Lindor hits leadoff homer and grand slam as Mets pound Gerrit Cole and rout Yankees 12-2," September 2026.
  • Yanks Go Yard, "Yankees News: Gerrit Cole concern, former top prospect lands with Nationals, Clarke Schmidt," September 2026.

One Hand Gesture From Shaq at Tiger Stadium Just Reopened Angel Reese’s Worst Week of the Year

Angel Reese held up her phone on the Tiger Stadium sideline Saturday, angling for a selfie with Shaquille O’Neal before...
Read More
One Hand Gesture From Shaq at Tiger Stadium Just Reopened Angel Reese’s Worst Week of the Year

Mike Vick Took Off His Headset to Kneel Out a Win and Then Looked Up at a Play He Never Called

Mike Vick Took Off His Headset to Kneel Out a Win and Then Looked Up at a Play He Never...
Read More
Mike Vick Took Off His Headset to Kneel Out a Win and Then Looked Up at a Play He Never Called

An Ohio State Corner Jawed at Dan Lanning’s Bench Down 24 Points and Then Got His Answer Without a Word

Oregon had just stretched its lead to 38-14 early in the fourth quarter when Ohio State defensive back Jermaine Mathews...
Read More
An Ohio State Corner Jawed at Dan Lanning’s Bench Down 24 Points and Then Got His Answer Without a Word

Lane Kiffin Told Tiger Stadium to Start Drinking Early and Then Heard Back From It on Live TV

Late in the fourth quarter Saturday, an ABC field microphone caught a fan hollering a two-word greeting at Lane Kiffin...
Read More
Lane Kiffin Told Tiger Stadium to Start Drinking Early and Then Heard Back From It on Live TV

Dave Portnoy Just Proposed a Punishment for the Loser of Ohio State and Michigan That Neither Fan Base Can Stomach

Michigan didn’t allow a touchdown in regulation at the Big House on Saturday and still lost 15-6 to Michigan State.That’s...
Read More
Dave Portnoy Just Proposed a Punishment for the Loser of Ohio State and Michigan That Neither Fan Base Can Stomach

One Rule Most Fans Don’t Know Turned a Fake Incomplete Pass Into the Wildest Finish of the High School Season

With six seconds left in a South Dakota semifinal, Bennett County quarterback Maddux Risse watched a lateral smack the turf...
Read More
One Rule Most Fans Don’t Know Turned a Fake Incomplete Pass Into the Wildest Finish of the High School Season

Kentucky Fans Painted Tennessee’s Rock Blue at Midnight and Then Made a 4 AM Phone Call

Just after midnight Saturday, a small crew of Kentucky fans rolled up to The Rock in Knoxville carrying buckets of...
Read More
Kentucky Fans Painted Tennessee’s Rock Blue at Midnight and Then Made a 4 AM Phone Call

Luka Doncic Got a Kings Fan Tossed for One Chest Pass and Forgot Who Coaches Him

Late in the third quarter in Sacramento, a courtside Kings fan scooped up a loose ball and fired a two-handed...
Read More
Luka Doncic Got a Kings Fan Tossed for One Chest Pass and Forgot Who Coaches Him

Ten SEC Teams Showed Up in ESPN’s Playoff Reveal and Curt Cignetti Had a Theory About Why

Curt Cignetti’s Hoosiers opened Tuesday’s first playoff rankings at No. 4, which would hand them a first-round bye if the...
Read More
Ten SEC Teams Showed Up in ESPN’s Playoff Reveal and Curt Cignetti Had a Theory About Why

Michigan Is Collecting Urine From Rivalry Tailgaters and Has Big Plans for Every Drop

Somewhere outside Michigan Stadium on Saturday, a volunteer will stand next to a urinal and ask a guy in a...
Read More
Michigan Is Collecting Urine From Rivalry Tailgaters and Has Big Plans for Every Drop

Get Free Email Alerts

Latest news