Drew Rasmussen walked off the Tropicana Field mound after four innings Wednesday having allowed one run on 48 pitches.
Kevin Cash had decided the ace’s night was over before Rasmussen threw a single pitch, and Milwaukee made him pay almost immediately.
Then the Rays manager stepped to the podium and defended the move like a man who learned nothing from 2020.
The Rays Burned Their Plan Before the Game Even Started
Rasmussen was starting on three days’ rest for the first time in his career as a full-time starter, four days after throwing 89 pitches in 3 2/3 innings in Game 2.
Tampa Bay put him in that spot because it burned scheduled Game 5 starter Nick Martinez out of the bullpen in Tuesday’s 12-inning win.
The Brewers got to him once in the second, when Cooper Pratt singled home Brice Turang.
After that, Rasmussen slammed the door with two hits allowed, four strikeouts, zero walks and a 1-2-3 fourth inning.
Cash sent right-hander Kevin Kelly out to start the fifth anyway.
The Bottom of the Order Did the Damage Again
Kelly gave up three straight one-out singles to Pratt, Garrett Mitchell and David Hamilton, the seventh, eighth and ninth hitters in Milwaukee’s lineup.
Hamilton’s single scored Pratt for a 2-0 lead against a Rays lineup that would score exactly once all night.
In both World Series elimination games Cash lost after pulling a cruising starter, the hit that started the collapse came from the bottom third of the order.
On October 27, 2020, Blake Snell had nine strikeouts and a 1-0 lead when Austin Barnes, the Dodgers’ No. 9 hitter, singled on his 73rd pitch with one out in the sixth.
Cash pulled the 2018 Cy Young winner, and six pitches later the Dodgers led 2-1 on their way to a title-clinching 3-1 win.
Six years and one day later, the reliever brought in to handle Milwaukee’s 7-8-9 hitters couldn’t get a single one of them out before the run scored.
The whole sales pitch for the quick hook is protecting a starter from the dangerous part of the lineup, and both times the soft part of the lineup ended the Rays’ season instead.
The Easiest Call in the World
“He’s a stud. That guy is a stud. His stuff was as sharp as it could have been. We had gone into the game saying it was 60 pitches or four innings. Stuck to that. That was the easiest call in the world to take him out of the ballgame,” Cash said.
Rasmussen took the hit for his manager, saying the Rays were doing their best to protect him and that “their biggest enemy is myself.”
Every Rays fan who has October 27, 2020 burned into their brain heard the echo of Cash saying back then that he only regretted pulling Snell “because it didn’t work out.”
Sure, the Arm Was a Real Concern
Rasmussen has had three major elbow surgeries, and the Rays gave him extra rest in 27 of his 35 starts this year.
His career short-rest line going in was five earned runs on nine hits over seven innings across four starts.
All of that is a fine reason to ease off in June, but it’s a lousy reason to hand the ball to Kevin Kelly with a championship on the line and your ace mowing hitters down.
Rasmussen Threw 101 Pitches Against the Yankees and 48 in the Game That Mattered Most
This same pitcher threw 101 pitches over eight innings against the Yankees on October 3 and 95 over seven against Cleveland on October 18, then got cut off at 48 with the season hanging on every out.
Add Snell’s 73 to Rasmussen’s 48 and Cash has yanked two aces out of World Series elimination games after 121 combined pitches, just 20 more than Rasmussen threw by himself in one ALDS start this month.
The Brewers scored one run off Rasmussen and three off the relievers who replaced him, so take away the bullpen’s damage and this game sits tied 1-1.
Cash and pitching coach Kyle Snyder drew up that 60-pitch ceiling together, and Cash is the one who stuck to it after Rasmussen came in well under it with a clean fourth inning.
The old-school managers of the 70s and 80s would have taken one look at Rasmussen’s 1-2-3 fourth and told the bullpen phone to stop ringing.
Tampa Bay now has to decide on Rasmussen’s $20 million club option for 2027, and the bigger question in that front office should be whether the guy holding the pitch-count sheet gets a third World Series to manage this way.
The Rays built a 60-pitch plan for the biggest night in franchise history, and Milwaukee is holding its first championship trophy because Tampa wouldn’t let its best pitcher throw one more inning.
Sources:
- ESPN Staff, “World Series Game 5: Takeaways as Brewers beat Rays, clinch title,” ESPN, October 28, 2026.
- ESPN Staff, “Rays proud of expectation-defying season despite World Series loss,” ESPN, October 28, 2026.
- MLB.com Staff, “Rasmussen lauds Rays, ponders 2027 after starting Game 5 on short rest,” MLB.com, October 28, 2026.
- CBS Sports Staff, “Brewers win 2026 World Series: How Milwaukee’s first championship in franchise history came together,” CBS Sports, October 28, 2026.
- CBS Sports Staff, “Rays’ Drew Rasmussen: Takes loss in Game 5,” CBS Sports, October 28, 2026.
- Associated Press, “Brewers beat the Rays 4-1 in Game 5 to win their first World Series title,” 13WHAM, October 28, 2026.
- Yahoo Sports Staff, “The ‘easiest’ World Series decision cost the Rays everything,” Yahoo Sports, October 29, 2026.
- Yahoo Sports Staff, “Kevin Cash Just Showed Rays Fans How Much He’s Changed in October,” Yahoo Sports, October 2026.
- MLB.com Staff, “Rasmussen puts Rays on his back again to build on historic postseason,” MLB.com, October 19, 2026.
- Jeff Passan, [title to be added by editor], ESPN, October 28, 2026.
- Associated Press, “Cashed Out: Rays manager roasted for pulling Snell in Game 6,” WFLA, October 28, 2020.
- Yahoo Sports Staff, “World Series Game 6: Rays decision to pull Blake Snell immediately backfires,” Yahoo Sports, October 27, 2020.
- Sports Illustrated Staff, “Blake Snell ‘Disappointed’ by Early Exit From Game 6,” Sports Illustrated, October 28, 2020.
- Sports With Balls, comparison of the bottom-of-the-order hits that followed the 2020 Snell hook and the 2026 Rasmussen hook, verified against 2020 AP and 2026 ESPN and AP reporting, October 29, 2026.
- Sports With Balls, count of Rasmussen’s October 2026 pitch totals and combined Snell-Rasmussen elimination-game pitch count, compiled from MLB.com, ESPN and AP game reporting, October 29, 2026.

