One Embarrassing Play Exposed Why Toronto Hasn’t Won a Stanley Cup in 59 Years

Auston Matthews, Easton Cowan and Morgan Rielly crossed the Nashville blue line Tuesday night with nobody between them and Juuse Saros.

Three Maple Leafs, one goalie, zero defenders, and somehow the scoreboard never budged.

When the coach got asked about it afterward, the name he pointed at wasn’t the one anybody at the bar expected.

Three Guys, One Goalie and No Goal

It happened in a 4-4 overtime at Scotiabank Arena, after the Leafs had already clawed back from a three-goal hole.

The Hot Stove’s game review called it one of the more absurd sequences you’ll ever see in three-on-three overtime, and that’s being polite.

Instead of Matthews putting his head down and charging the net, the trio rolled in side by side like three guys waiting for someone else to grab the check.

The puck went sideways, then sideways again, while Predators skaters came tearing back to the crease.

Cowan finally fired instead of returning the puck to Matthews, who was sitting on what looked like a back-door tap-in.

Saros shut the door, and Nashville’s own team site listed that stop as a highlight of his night.

The Coach Skipped the Kid and Went Straight to the Captain

Hiller didn’t hang it on the young winger who took the shot.

“I think 34 should’ve just taken that one straight down,” he said.

That’s Matthews, the captain, the highest-paid guy on the ice.

Then Hiller tried to wave the whole thing off with a joke: “We’ll call it a one-on-one.”

Translation for the tailgate crowd: a three-on-zero that doesn’t score is apparently getting reclassified so nobody has to watch it on loop.

Matthews Saved Everybody From a Full Roast

With the clock running out, William Nylander stripped Roman Josi, drove the slot and Matthews buried the loose puck with 14 seconds left.

That capped a four-point night for Matthews in a 5-4 win, and No. 1 overall pick Gavin McKenna scored his first NHL goal along the way.

Hiller said he felt “something special from Auston” – which is easy to say once the guy you just called out bails you out.

Why Wetzel Couldn’t Let It Go

Dan Wetzel posted the clip the next day, and his point was simple: those ten seconds looked like every Leafs spring since the last Cup in 1967.

The man isn’t wrong about the pattern.

Toronto went 32-36-14 last season and finished dead last in the Atlantic.

They lost their last seven games, missed the playoffs for the first time since 2015-16, and have won just two playoff series since 2004.

Craig Berube got fired on May 13, and a franchise that once had the league’s longest postseason streak is starting over with a new coach and a new GM.

Old-Time Hockey Says Shoot the Puck

Any guy who played on a frozen pond in the 70s knows the rule: three on none, your best player goes to the net and the other two hunt rebounds.

The Hot Stove breakdown said the rush looked hesitant from the jump because they went in as a group instead of sending Matthews alone.

That’s the whole problem in Toronto, packed into one rush – too much thinking, not enough hunger.

Vegas Is Waiting With a Familiar Face

Now the Leafs hit the road for Vegas, Colorado and Utah, starting with a Golden Knights team that has Mitch Marner on it.

Marner put up 29 playoff points while helping Vegas reach the Stanley Cup Final last spring.

If Matthews gets another three-on-zero in the desert, he’d better skip the group project.

So which is it – a fun early-season blooper, or proof that this team still freezes when the door swings wide open?

Send this to your buddy in the Leafs jersey who swore the curse died the minute Berube walked out the door.

Sources:

  • Canadian Press, “Maple Leafs top Predators in overtime as McKenna scores first NHL goal,” TSN, Oct. 6, 2026.
  • Mark Masters, “Matthews shows ‘will to win’ in sparking Leafs’ comeback,” TSN, Oct. 7, 2026.
  • Maple Leafs Hot Stove, “Game Review: Matthews, McKenna deliver the headlines in a Maple Leafs comeback thriller,” Maple Leafs Hot Stove, Oct. 7, 2026.
  • Maple Leafs Hot Stove, “Jim Hiller on whether it looked like the Matthews of old vs. Nashville,” Maple Leafs Hot Stove, Oct. 7, 2026.
  • FanRecap, “Matthews Just Gave Leafs Fans A Glimpse They’ve Been Waiting For,” FanRecap, Oct. 2026.
  • Nashville Predators On SI, “Nashville Predators Stock Exchange After Overtime Loss to Toronto Maple Leafs,” Sports Illustrated, Oct. 7, 2026.
  • The Hockey Writers, “Maple Leafs News & Rumours: McKenna Gets His Moment & Matthews Finds His Game,” The Hockey Writers, Oct. 7, 2026.
  • NHL.com, “Hiller hired as Maple Leafs coach, replaces Berube,” NHL.com, June 17, 2026.
  • CJME, “Jim Hiller hired as Maple Leafs head coach,” CJME, June 17, 2026.
  • ClutchPoints, “Craig Berube makes honest Mitch Marner admission,” ClutchPoints, July 2026.
  • Dan Wetzel, social media post on the Maple Leafs’ three-on-zero, Oct. 7, 2026.

One Hand Gesture From Shaq at Tiger Stadium Just Reopened Angel Reese’s Worst Week of the Year

Angel Reese held up her phone on the Tiger Stadium sideline Saturday, angling for a selfie with Shaquille O’Neal before...
Read More
One Hand Gesture From Shaq at Tiger Stadium Just Reopened Angel Reese’s Worst Week of the Year

Mike Vick Took Off His Headset to Kneel Out a Win and Then Looked Up at a Play He Never Called

Mike Vick Took Off His Headset to Kneel Out a Win and Then Looked Up at a Play He Never...
Read More
Mike Vick Took Off His Headset to Kneel Out a Win and Then Looked Up at a Play He Never Called

An Ohio State Corner Jawed at Dan Lanning’s Bench Down 24 Points and Then Got His Answer Without a Word

Oregon had just stretched its lead to 38-14 early in the fourth quarter when Ohio State defensive back Jermaine Mathews...
Read More
An Ohio State Corner Jawed at Dan Lanning’s Bench Down 24 Points and Then Got His Answer Without a Word

Lane Kiffin Told Tiger Stadium to Start Drinking Early and Then Heard Back From It on Live TV

Late in the fourth quarter Saturday, an ABC field microphone caught a fan hollering a two-word greeting at Lane Kiffin...
Read More
Lane Kiffin Told Tiger Stadium to Start Drinking Early and Then Heard Back From It on Live TV

Dave Portnoy Just Proposed a Punishment for the Loser of Ohio State and Michigan That Neither Fan Base Can Stomach

Michigan didn’t allow a touchdown in regulation at the Big House on Saturday and still lost 15-6 to Michigan State.That’s...
Read More
Dave Portnoy Just Proposed a Punishment for the Loser of Ohio State and Michigan That Neither Fan Base Can Stomach

One Rule Most Fans Don’t Know Turned a Fake Incomplete Pass Into the Wildest Finish of the High School Season

With six seconds left in a South Dakota semifinal, Bennett County quarterback Maddux Risse watched a lateral smack the turf...
Read More
One Rule Most Fans Don’t Know Turned a Fake Incomplete Pass Into the Wildest Finish of the High School Season

Kentucky Fans Painted Tennessee’s Rock Blue at Midnight and Then Made a 4 AM Phone Call

Just after midnight Saturday, a small crew of Kentucky fans rolled up to The Rock in Knoxville carrying buckets of...
Read More
Kentucky Fans Painted Tennessee’s Rock Blue at Midnight and Then Made a 4 AM Phone Call

Luka Doncic Got a Kings Fan Tossed for One Chest Pass and Forgot Who Coaches Him

Late in the third quarter in Sacramento, a courtside Kings fan scooped up a loose ball and fired a two-handed...
Read More
Luka Doncic Got a Kings Fan Tossed for One Chest Pass and Forgot Who Coaches Him

Ten SEC Teams Showed Up in ESPN’s Playoff Reveal and Curt Cignetti Had a Theory About Why

Curt Cignetti’s Hoosiers opened Tuesday’s first playoff rankings at No. 4, which would hand them a first-round bye if the...
Read More
Ten SEC Teams Showed Up in ESPN’s Playoff Reveal and Curt Cignetti Had a Theory About Why

Michigan Is Collecting Urine From Rivalry Tailgaters and Has Big Plans for Every Drop

Somewhere outside Michigan Stadium on Saturday, a volunteer will stand next to a urinal and ask a guy in a...
Read More
Michigan Is Collecting Urine From Rivalry Tailgaters and Has Big Plans for Every Drop

Get Free Email Alerts

Latest news