The Pirates Traded for a Shutdown Reliever and Somehow Got Him Covered in Hives Instead

Luke Weaver was the best reliever available at the trade deadline.

Then he put on a Pirates uniform and the universe found a way to punish him for it.

What's actually happened to him since the trade explains everything about why this franchise has the reputation it does.

He Was Excellent. Then He Became a Pirate.

Pittsburgh landed Weaver from the Mets just hours before the Aug. 3 deadline, giving up only shortstop prospect Sammy Stafura for a reliever who'd been arguably the best bullpen arm on the entire trade market. The numbers backed it up. Weaver posted a 1.84 ERA and a 0.82 WHIP across 44 innings for New York, striking out 45 batters in 42 appearances and looking like exactly the kind of stabilizing, late-inning arm a bullpen builds around. The Mets were even paying down a chunk of his remaining $22 million contract just to make the deal work. On paper, Pittsburgh got a steal.

Since arriving, Weaver has posted a 5.79 ERA in limited innings. That's not a slump. That's a completely different pitcher wearing the same jersey number.

And Then the Poison Ivy Showed Up

Here's where this stops being a normal cold streak and starts becoming a genuinely cursed-franchise story. Weaver revealed this week that he's been battling a severe poison ivy outbreak across his lower body for nearly a month, dating back to a series in Miami from Aug. 11-13, when he brushed up against a bush on the road. What started as a rash turned into hives covering his entire lower half, compounded by a sinus cold that hit around the same time. Pirates manager Don Kelly didn't sugarcoat how bad it got. "He got a really bad case of it," Kelly said. "It's been tough to kick. It was a really tough case." Weaver's medical staff has been working to clear it up for weeks, and by Kelly's own account, it's only recently started improving.

Try pitching in the late innings of a big-league game with hives covering your legs, barely sleeping, and a cold on top of it. That's not an excuse teams typically get to make for a guy posting a 5-plus ERA. It's also not the kind of thing that happens to a normal trade acquisition on a normal team.

This Is Just What Being a Pirate Does to People

Pittsburgh fans didn't need one more data point to believe their franchise operates under some kind of curse, but they got one anyway. The team gave up almost nothing to land a shutdown reliever at the deadline, and within two weeks of the trade closing, that reliever had wandered into a patch of poison ivy severe enough to derail an entire month of his season. Nobody's blaming the front office for this one. There's no scouting report that flags "will get attacked by a plant in Miami." But that's exactly the kind of misfortune this organization has built its entire modern identity around — good process, snakebit results, over and over again.

Weaver still has three weeks left in 2026 and a full 2027 season under contract to turn this around, and by all accounts the poison ivy is finally clearing. Whether the numbers follow is the real test. But for now, the Pirates picked up a genuine difference-maker at the deadline and got a guy who couldn't sleep through the night because of a plant. That's not bad luck. At this point, that's just Pittsburgh.


Sources:

  • MLB.com, "Luke Weaver dealing with case of poison ivy," September 2026.
  • Sports Illustrated, "Pirates' Luke Weaver Can Still Thrive Despite Unusual Ailment," September 2026.
  • Baseball America, "Mets Acquire Sammy Stafura In Luke Weaver Trade With Pirates," August 2026.

One Hand Gesture From Shaq at Tiger Stadium Just Reopened Angel Reese’s Worst Week of the Year

Angel Reese held up her phone on the Tiger Stadium sideline Saturday, angling for a selfie with Shaquille O’Neal before...
Read More
One Hand Gesture From Shaq at Tiger Stadium Just Reopened Angel Reese’s Worst Week of the Year

Mike Vick Took Off His Headset to Kneel Out a Win and Then Looked Up at a Play He Never Called

Mike Vick Took Off His Headset to Kneel Out a Win and Then Looked Up at a Play He Never...
Read More
Mike Vick Took Off His Headset to Kneel Out a Win and Then Looked Up at a Play He Never Called

An Ohio State Corner Jawed at Dan Lanning’s Bench Down 24 Points and Then Got His Answer Without a Word

Oregon had just stretched its lead to 38-14 early in the fourth quarter when Ohio State defensive back Jermaine Mathews...
Read More
An Ohio State Corner Jawed at Dan Lanning’s Bench Down 24 Points and Then Got His Answer Without a Word

Lane Kiffin Told Tiger Stadium to Start Drinking Early and Then Heard Back From It on Live TV

Late in the fourth quarter Saturday, an ABC field microphone caught a fan hollering a two-word greeting at Lane Kiffin...
Read More
Lane Kiffin Told Tiger Stadium to Start Drinking Early and Then Heard Back From It on Live TV

Dave Portnoy Just Proposed a Punishment for the Loser of Ohio State and Michigan That Neither Fan Base Can Stomach

Michigan didn’t allow a touchdown in regulation at the Big House on Saturday and still lost 15-6 to Michigan State.That’s...
Read More
Dave Portnoy Just Proposed a Punishment for the Loser of Ohio State and Michigan That Neither Fan Base Can Stomach

One Rule Most Fans Don’t Know Turned a Fake Incomplete Pass Into the Wildest Finish of the High School Season

With six seconds left in a South Dakota semifinal, Bennett County quarterback Maddux Risse watched a lateral smack the turf...
Read More
One Rule Most Fans Don’t Know Turned a Fake Incomplete Pass Into the Wildest Finish of the High School Season

Kentucky Fans Painted Tennessee’s Rock Blue at Midnight and Then Made a 4 AM Phone Call

Just after midnight Saturday, a small crew of Kentucky fans rolled up to The Rock in Knoxville carrying buckets of...
Read More
Kentucky Fans Painted Tennessee’s Rock Blue at Midnight and Then Made a 4 AM Phone Call

Luka Doncic Got a Kings Fan Tossed for One Chest Pass and Forgot Who Coaches Him

Late in the third quarter in Sacramento, a courtside Kings fan scooped up a loose ball and fired a two-handed...
Read More
Luka Doncic Got a Kings Fan Tossed for One Chest Pass and Forgot Who Coaches Him

Ten SEC Teams Showed Up in ESPN’s Playoff Reveal and Curt Cignetti Had a Theory About Why

Curt Cignetti’s Hoosiers opened Tuesday’s first playoff rankings at No. 4, which would hand them a first-round bye if the...
Read More
Ten SEC Teams Showed Up in ESPN’s Playoff Reveal and Curt Cignetti Had a Theory About Why

Michigan Is Collecting Urine From Rivalry Tailgaters and Has Big Plans for Every Drop

Somewhere outside Michigan Stadium on Saturday, a volunteer will stand next to a urinal and ask a guy in a...
Read More
Michigan Is Collecting Urine From Rivalry Tailgaters and Has Big Plans for Every Drop

Get Free Email Alerts

Latest news